1256 Bay St is a 4,590 square foot house on a 3,000 square foot lot with 4 bedrooms and 2 bathrooms. 1256 Bay St is a house currently priced at $875,000.

How many photos are available for this home?

DistressedRealEstate.net has 10 photos of 1256 Bay St.

How much is this home worth?

Based on DistressedRealEstate.net's Staten Island, NY data, we estimate the home's value is $1,159,600.

How long has this home been listed on DistressedRealEstate.net?

1256 Bay St has been listed on DistressedRealEstate.net since April 14, 2025.

How competitive is the market for this home?

Based on DistressedRealEstate.net's market data, we calculate that market competition in 10305, this home's neighborhood, is somewhat competitive. This home sell's for about 25% below listed price.

What’s the full address of this home?

The full address for this home is 1256 Bay St, Staten Island, NY 10305.

1256 Bay St, Staten Island, NY 10305

Hot Deal

Last Updated: April 15, 2025

1256 Bay St, Staten Island, NY, 10305

Asking price$ 875,000

Hot Deal

NEWAPR 14, 2025

Multi Family Home

Asking price

$875,000

Garage

Other Exterior

1256 Bay St

    
bool(false)

bool(true)

bool(true)

int(0)

Asking price

$875,000

Staten Island, NY 10305

—

Richmond County

Favorite

Calculate Flipping Profit

Please note!

The Hot Deal section reflects only properties processed within the last 20 days and it is renewing on a daily basis.
If you liked a property, you need to add it into your favorites list to be able to see it after the allotted time period.

Property details for 1256 Bay St

Sells for

75%

of EARV

Status

For Sale

Days on market

9 days

Type

Multi Family Home

Zoning Districts

R3A

C1-2

Year Built

1931

Stories

The description and property data below may have been provided by a third party, the homeowner or public records.

Amazing opportunity! This great mixed use building features 3 levels, plus a basement and boasts 4590 sf. The 3 units feature a retail level with 2100 sf and 2 apartments with each one being 1245 sf. Located in the beautiful Rosebank area of Staten Island and is only a few minutes from the Verrazano bridge. The building needs to be restored and therefore is priced below market value at 875k. Sold in 'as is' condition.

Property features

Bedrooms

Bedrooms:
Bedrooms:
4
4

Garage and Parking

Parking Features:
Parking Features:
On Street
On Street

Bathrooms

Full Bathrooms:
Full Bathrooms:
2
2
Total Bathrooms:
Total Bathrooms:
2
2

Heating and Cooling

Heating Features:
Heating Features:
Steam, Natural Gas
Steam, Natural Gas
Heating:
Heating:
Yes
Yes

Homeowners Association

Association:
Association:
No
No
Calculated Total Monthly Association Fees:
Calculated Total Monthly Association Fees:
0
0

Utilities

Electric:
Electric:
110
110
Sewer:
Sewer:
City
City

Land Info

Lot Size Acres:
Lot Size Acres:
0.0688705
0.0688705
Lot Size Dimensions:
Lot Size Dimensions:
30x100
30x100
Lot Size Square Feet:
Lot Size Square Feet:
3000
3000

Multi-Unit Info

Bedrooms in Unit-2:
Bedrooms in Unit-2:
2
2
Bedrooms in Unit-3:
Bedrooms in Unit-3:
2
2
Number of Units:
Number of Units:
3
3
Total Bathrooms in Unit-2:
Total Bathrooms in Unit-2:
1
1
Total Bathrooms in Unit-3:
Total Bathrooms in Unit-3:
1
1
Total Rooms in Unit-1:
Total Rooms in Unit-1:
1
1
Total Rooms in Unit-2:
Total Rooms in Unit-2:
4
4
Total Rooms in Unit-3:
Total Rooms in Unit-3:
4
4

Building and Construction

Building Area Total:
Building Area Total:
4590
4590
Building Exterior Type:
Building Exterior Type:
Brick
Brick
Construction Materials:
Construction Materials:
Brick
Brick
Foundation Details:
Foundation Details:
Full
Full
Levels or Stories:
Levels or Stories:
3
3
Property Age:
Property Age:
94
94
Property Condition:
Property Condition:
Poor
Poor
Total Square Feet Living:
Total Square Feet Living:
4590
4590
Year Built Details:
Year Built Details:
Approx
Approx
Year Built:
Year Built:
1931
1931

Other Property Info

Annual Tax Amount:
Annual Tax Amount:
9007
9007
Area:
Area:
Rosebank
Rosebank
County:
County:
Richmond
Richmond
MLS Area Minor:
MLS Area Minor:
Rosebank
Rosebank
Parcel Number:
Parcel Number:
02857-0033
02857-0033
Property Subtype:
Property Subtype:
3F
3F
Source Listing Status:
Source Listing Status:
Active
Active
Source Neighborhood:
Source Neighborhood:
Rosebank
Rosebank
Source Property Type:
Source Property Type:
Residential Income
Residential Income
Source System Name:
Source System Name:
C2C
C2C
Zoning:
Zoning:
C1-2
C1-2

Primary Land Use and Tax Lot Information

for 1256 Bay St

Lot Map

1256 BAY STREET, 10305

Building Info

DOB Overview:

View Details
Building Class:

S2
Residence - Multiple Use: Primarily Two Family With One Store Or Office
Year Built:

1931
Number of Buildings:

1
Floors on Main Building:

3
Building Dimensions:

30'42'
Actual Square Footage:

4,590
Calculated Square Footage:

3,780
Residential Floor Area:

2,490
Commercial Floor Area:

2,100
Retail Floor Area:

2,100
Total Units:

3
Residential Units:

2
Basement:

Unknown

Lot Info and Address

Address:

1256 BAY STREET
Zip Code:

10305
Borough:

Staten Island (5)
Block — Lot:

2857 — 33
BBLE:

5028570033
Lot Buildings:
BIN

Name

5042881 1256 BAY STREET
Ownership:
Land Use:

04
Mixed Residential & Commercial Buildings
Lot Dimensions:

30'100'
Calculated Lot Perimeter:

266.01 ft
Acres:

0.07
Lot Area:

3,000
Lot Type:

Inside

BIN	Name
5042881	1256 BAY STREET

Zoning and FAR

Zoning Districts:

R3A
Lower-density residence district
Commercial Overlays:

C1-2
Commercial districts that are predominantly residential in character
DCP Zoning Map:

View Details
Actual FAR:

1.53
Max Residential FAR:

0.50
Max Commercial FAR:

0
Max Facility FAR:

1
Max Residential Sqft:

1,500
Buildable Residential Sqft:

0
Residential Area Distribution:

Show more Hide

Property Price History

for 1256 Bay St

Date	Event	Price	Price/Sqft	Source
Apr 14, 2025	Listed	$875,000	$191	StatenIsland

Sold Homes

near 1256 Bay St

Address	Price	Built	Beds	Baths	Sqft	Lot Size	Distance
78 Maryland Ave Staten Island, NY 10305MF	$970,000 04/11/2025	1901	8	3	2,628 -1,962difference	4,640	0.09 mi
78 Maryland AveMF Staten Island, NY 10305 1901 Built 2,628 -1,962 Sqft 4,640 Lot Size 0.09 mi Distance
704 Tompkins Ave Staten Island, NY 10305MF	$847,000 02/12/2025	1905	4	2	2,328 -2,262	4,600	0.33 mi
704 Tompkins AveMF Staten Island, NY 10305 1905 Built 2,328 -2,262 Sqft 4,600 Lot Size 0.33 mi Distance
118 Pouch Ter Staten Island, NY 10305MF	$900,000 04/17/2025	1975	6	4	2,104 -2,486	3,886	0.89 mi
118 Pouch TerMF Staten Island, NY 10305 1975 Built 2,104 -2,486 Sqft 3,886 Lot Size 0.89 mi Distance
487 Clifton Ave Staten Island, NY 10305MF	$828,000 02/26/2025	1965	5	3	2,016 -2,574	3,960	0.68 mi
487 Clifton AveMF Staten Island, NY 10305 1965 Built 2,016 -2,574 Sqft 3,960 Lot Size 0.68 mi Distance
50 Clifton Ave Staten Island, NY 10305MF	$680,000 11/21/2024	1901	3	4	1,899 -2,691	6,950	0.19 mi
50 Clifton AveMF Staten Island, NY 10305 1901 Built 1,899 -2,691 Sqft 6,950 Lot Size 0.19 mi Distance
25 Waterview Ct Staten Island, NY 10305MF	$800,000 03/14/2025	1998	4	5	1,232 -3,358	1,402	0.19 mi
25 Waterview CtMF Staten Island, NY 10305 1998 Built 1,232 -3,358 Sqft 1,402 Lot Size 0.19 mi Distance
251 Maryland Ave Staten Island, NY 10305MF	$800,000 02/13/2025	2002	—	4	1,560 -3,030	3,125	0.26 mi
251 Maryland AveMF Staten Island, NY 10305 2002 Built 1,560 -3,030 Sqft 3,125 Lot Size 0.26 mi Distance
74 Fingerboard Rd Staten Island, NY 10305MF	$750,000 03/14/2025	1901	4	2	1,616 -2,974	3,300	0.33 mi
74 Fingerboard RdMF Staten Island, NY 10305 1901 Built 1,616 -2,974 Sqft 3,300 Lot Size 0.33 mi Distance
179 St Marys Ave Staten Island, NY 10305MF	$581,000 04/08/2025	1915	2	1	1,560 -3,030	4,800	0.43 mi
179 St Marys AveMF Staten Island, NY 10305 1915 Built 1,560 -3,030 Sqft 4,800 Lot Size 0.43 mi Distance
230 Chestnut Ave Staten Island, NY 10305MF	$600,000 03/11/2025	1915	4	2	1,890 -2,700	1,920	0.56 mi
230 Chestnut AveMF Staten Island, NY 10305 1915 Built 1,890 -2,700 Sqft 1,920 Lot Size 0.56 mi Distance

Show more Hide

Homes For Sale

near 1256 Bay St

Address	Price	Built	Beds	Baths	Sqft	Lot Size	Distance
82 Piedmont Ave Staten Island, NY 10305SF	$2,295,000 97 days ago	2024	4	4	4,500 -90difference	4,000	0.90 mi
82 Piedmont AveSF Staten Island, NY 10305 2024 Built 4,500 -90 Sqft 4,000 Lot Size 0.90 mi Distance
337 Howard Ave Staten Island, NY 10301SF	$1,599,000 141 days ago	1980	4	5	4,472 -118	35,009	1.32 mi
337 Howard AveSF Staten Island, NY 10301 1980 Built 4,472 -118 Sqft 35,009 Lot Size 1.32 mi Distance
21 87th St Brooklyn, NY 11209SF	$3,750,000 168 days ago	1925	4	4	4,400 -190	4,000	1.60 mi
21 87th StSF Brooklyn, NY 11209 1925 Built 4,400 -190 Sqft 4,000 Lot Size 1.60 mi Distance
12 Cross St Staten Island, NY 10304MF	$900,000 321 days ago	2008	4	3	4,376 -214	1,875	1.17 mi
12 Cross StMF Staten Island, NY 10304 2008 Built 4,376 -214 Sqft 1,875 Lot Size 1.17 mi Distance
1281 Richmond Rd Staten Island, NY 10304MF	$1,298,000 86 days ago	1980	5	6	4,266 -324	9,034	1.92 mi
1281 Richmond RdMF Staten Island, NY 10304 1980 Built 4,266 -324 Sqft 9,034 Lot Size 1.92 mi Distance

Schools

serving 1256 Bay St

School Name	Rating	Grades	Parent Rating	Distance
Ps 78 100 Tompkins Avenue, Staten Island, NY 10304	4 / 10	K−5		0.98 mi
K−5 Grades Parent Rating 0.98 mi Distance
Ps 57 Hubert H Humphrey 140 Palma Drive, Staten Island, NY 10304	5 / 10	K−5		0.96 mi
K−5 Grades Parent Rating 0.96 mi Distance
St. Joseph Parochial School 139 Saint Mary's Ave, Staten Island, NY 10305	—	K−8		0.38 mi
K−8 Grades Parent Rating 0.38 mi Distance
Ps 13 M L Lindenmeyer 191 Vermont Avenue, Staten Island, NY 10305	7 / 10	K−5		0.21 mi
K−5 Grades Parent Rating 0.21 mi Distance
Is 49 Bertha A Dreyfus 101 Warren Street, Staten Island, NY 10304	4 / 10	6−8		1.00 mi
6−8 Grades Parent Rating 1.00 mi Distance
The Richard H Hungerford School 715 Ocean Terrace, Staten Island, NY 10301	—	6−12		0.84 mi
6−12 Grades Parent Rating 0.84 mi Distance
St. John Villa Academy-Elementary 57 Cleveland Pl, Staten Island, NY 10305	—	K−8		0.75 mi
K−8 Grades Parent Rating 0.75 mi Distance
Geller House School 77 Chicago Avenue, Staten Island, NY 10305	—	5−11	—	0.78 mi
5−11 Grades — Parent Rating 0.78 mi Distance
Geller House School 77 Chicago Avenue, Staten Island, NY 10305	—	6−11		0.79 mi
6−11 Grades Parent Rating 0.79 mi Distance
Curtis High School 105 Hamilton Avenue, Staten Island, NY 10301	3 / 10	9−12		2.42 mi
9−12 Grades Parent Rating 2.42 mi Distance

Show more Hide

School service boundaries are intended to be used as reference only. To verify enrollment eligibility for a property, contact the school directly.