What is 119 Atlantic Ave?

119 Atlantic Ave is a 2,500 square foot house on a 10,019 square foot lot with 4 bedrooms and 2 bathrooms. 119 Atlantic Ave is a house currently priced at $749,000.

How many photos are available for this home?

DistressedRealEstate.net has 39 photos of 119 Atlantic Ave.

How much is this home worth?

Based on DistressedRealEstate.net's West Sayville, NY data, we estimate the home's value is $980,600.

How long has this home been listed on DistressedRealEstate.net?

119 Atlantic Ave has been listed on DistressedRealEstate.net since March 13, 2025.

When was this home built?

119 Atlantic Ave was built in 1917.

How competitive is the market for this home?

Based on DistressedRealEstate.net's market data, we calculate that market competition in 11796, this home's neighborhood, is somewhat competitive. This home sell's for about 24% below listed price.

What’s the full address of this home?

The full address for this home is 119 Atlantic Ave, West Sayville, NY 11796.

119 Atlantic Ave, West Sayville, NY 11796

Hot Deal

Last Updated: March 13, 2025

119 Atlantic Ave, West Sayville, NY, 11796

Asking price$ 749,000

Hot Deal

NEWMAR 13, 2025

Single Family Home

Town House

Asking price

$749,000

Yard

Yard

119 Atlantic Ave

    
bool(false)

bool(true)

bool(true)

int(0)

Asking price

$749,000

West Sayville, NY 11796

—

Suffolk County

Favorite

Calculate Flipping Profit

Please note!

The Hot Deal section reflects only properties processed within the last 20 days and it is renewing on a daily basis.
If you liked a property, you need to add it into your favorites list to be able to see it after the allotted time period.

Property details for 119 Atlantic Ave

Sells for

76%

of EARV

Status

For Sale

Days on market

1 day

Type

Single Family Home

Town House

Year Built

1917

Stories

Garage

Yes

Flood Factor

8 / 10

The description and property data below may have been provided by a third party, the homeowner or public records.

This charming circa 1913 Victorian underwent a tasteful full renovation and expansion in 1998, enhancing its original beauty and function. The design maintained authenticity while taking advantage of the southern exposed location and adding modern conveniences. Upon approach, especially in season, the completely organic grounds and garden path welcome you to the cover front porch with bench swing, the perfect place for evening sunsets. Enter the large foyer and through the original front door to the elegant living room. The kitchen area is a functional space with an open floor plan, island seating, lots of counters and a chefs gas range. The adjacent dining room overlooks the great room, and great it is, with floor to ceiling windows, french doors leading to the back yard, gas fireplace, custom mantle piece, and built-in shelving. It's truly the heart of the home. This level also features a home office that can double as a bedroom, plus a full bathroom. Up the grand staircase the second level features 3 bedrooms, including the primary with water views. All of the bedrooms boast walk in closets and custom shelving. A large laundry room with storage closet and full bathroom with original clawfoot tub, complete this floor. Outside the grounds offer mature stunning gardens, brick driveway and patio, 1.5-car garage and storage shed. Truly a quality home in a wonderful location, with immediate proximity to Greene's Creek Park, Maritime Museum grounds, Golf Course, West Ave Dock and more. Don't miss this gem!

Property features

Home Features

View:
View:
Water
Water

Homeowners Association

Calculated Total Monthly Association Fees:
Calculated Total Monthly Association Fees:
0
0

Bathrooms

Full Bathrooms:
Full Bathrooms:
2
2
Total Bathrooms:
Total Bathrooms:
2
2

Kitchen and Dining

Dining Area Level:
Dining Area Level:
First
First
Kitchen Level:
Kitchen Level:
First
First

Bedrooms

Bedroom 2 Level:
Bedroom 2 Level:
Second
Second
Bedroom 3 Level:
Bedroom 3 Level:
Second
Second
Bedrooms:
Bedrooms:
4
4

Garage and Parking

Garage Spaces:
Garage Spaces:
1
1
Parking Features:
Parking Features:
Driveway, Garage
Driveway, Garage
Parking Total:
Parking Total:
5
5

Land Info

Lot Description:
Lot Description:
Back Yard, Front Yard, Garden, Landscaped, Level
Back Yard, Front Yard, Garden, Landscaped, Level
Lot Size Acres:
Lot Size Acres:
0.2300046
0.2300046
Lot Size Square Feet:
Lot Size Square Feet:
10019
10019

Exterior and Lot Features

Fencing:
Fencing:
Back Yard
Back Yard
Garden
Other Structures:
Other Structures:
Garage(s), Shed(s)
Garage(s), Shed(s)
Patio And Porch Features:
Patio And Porch Features:
Patio, Porch
Patio, Porch

Heating and Cooling

Cooling Features:
Cooling Features:
Central Air
Central Air
Fireplace Features:
Fireplace Features:
Gas, Living Room
Gas, Living Room
Heating Features:
Heating Features:
Oil
Oil
Number of Fireplaces:
Number of Fireplaces:
1
1

School Information

Elementary School:
Elementary School:
Cherry Avenue Elementary School
Cherry Avenue Elementary School
High School District:
High School District:
Sayville
Sayville
High School:
High School:
Sayville High School
Sayville High School
Middle School:
Middle School:
Sayville Middle School
Sayville Middle School

Other Rooms

Basement Description:
Basement Description:
Bilco Door(s)
Bilco Door(s)
Basement Features:
Basement Features:
Bilco Door(s)
Bilco Door(s)
Den Level:
Den Level:
First
First
Family Room Level:
Family Room Level:
First
First
Living Room Level:
Living Room Level:
First
First
Total Rooms:
Total Rooms:
12
12

Utilities

Cable Available
Electricity Available
Natural Gas Available
Phone Available
Sewer:
Sewer:
Cesspool
Cesspool
Trash Collection Public
Water Available
Water Source:
Water Source:
Public
Public

Appliances

Dishwasher
Dryer
Gas Cooktop
Gas Oven
Gas Range
Laundry Features:
Laundry Features:
Laundry Room
Laundry Room
Oil Water Heater
Refrigerator
Stainless Steel Appliance(s)
Washer

Building and Construction

Architectural Style:
Architectural Style:
Traditional, Victorian
Traditional, Victorian
Attic:
Attic:
Pull Stairs
Pull Stairs
Building Area Source:
Building Area Source:
Public Records
Public Records
Building Area Total:
Building Area Total:
2553
2553
Construction Materials:
Construction Materials:
Frame
Frame
Direction Faces:
Direction Faces:
West
West
Levels:
Levels:
Two
Two
Property Age:
Property Age:
108
108
Property Condition:
Property Condition:
Updated/Remodeled
Updated/Remodeled
Total Square Feet Living:
Total Square Feet Living:
2500
2500
Year Built:
Year Built:
1917
1917

Other Property Info

Annual Tax Amount:
Annual Tax Amount:
13032.19
13032.19
County:
County:
Suffolk County
Suffolk County
Directions:
Directions:
Montauk Highway, To Atlantic Avenue -Southbound
Montauk Highway, To Atlantic Avenue -Southbound
Parcel Number:
Parcel Number:
0500-429-00-03-00-011-000
0500-429-00-03-00-011-000
Postal City:
Postal City:
West Sayville
West Sayville
Postal Code Plus 4:
Postal Code Plus 4:
1910
1910
Property Subtype:
Property Subtype:
Single Family Residence
Single Family Residence
Source Listing Status:
Source Listing Status:
Active
Active
Source Property Type:
Source Property Type:
Residential
Residential
Source System Name:
Source System Name:
C2C
C2C
Tax Year:
Tax Year:
2025
2025

Interior Features

Breakfast Bar
Built-in Features
Ceiling Fan(s)
Chefs Kitchen
Eat-in Kitchen
Entertainment Cabinets
Entrance Foyer
First Floor Bedroom
First Floor Full Bath
Flooring:
Flooring:
Hardwood
Hardwood
High Ceilings
His and Hers Closets
Kitchen Island
Natural Woodwork
Open Kitchen
Pantry
Soaking Tub
Storage
Walk-In Closet(s)
Washer/Dryer Hookup
Window Features:
Window Features:
Bay Window(s), Floor to Ceiling Windows, Oversized Windows
Bay Window(s), Floor to Ceiling Windows, Oversized Windows

Property Price History

for 119 Atlantic Ave

Date	Event	Price	Price/Sqft	Source
Mar 13, 2025	Listed	$749,000	$300	OneKeyMLS

Property Tax History

for 119 Atlantic Ave

Year	Taxes	Land	Additions	Total Assessment
2017	$10,046	$12,800	$27,700	$40,500
2016	$10,063	$12,800	$27,700	$40,500
2015	$10,170	$12,800	$27,700	$40,500
2014	$10,077	$12,800	$27,700	$40,500
2013	$9,799	$12,800	$27,700	$40,500
2012	$9,570	$12,800	$27,700	$40,500
2011	$9,235	$12,800	$27,700	$40,500
2010	$8,706	$12,800	$27,700	$40,500
2008	$8,451	$12,800	$27,700	$40,500

Show more Hide

Sold Homes

near 119 Atlantic Ave

Address	Price	Built	Beds	Baths	Sqft	Lot Size	Distance
104 Benson Ave Sayville, NY 11782SF	$1,100,000 10/07/2024	1967	5	3	2,564 +64difference	20,038	0.28 mi
104 Benson AveSF Sayville, NY 11782 1967 Built 2,564 +64 Sqft 20,038 Lot Size 0.28 mi Distance
123 Handsome Ave Sayville, NY 11782SF	$925,000 02/21/2025	1955	4	2	2,600 +100	29,185	0.58 mi
123 Handsome AveSF Sayville, NY 11782 1955 Built 2,600 +100 Sqft 29,185 Lot Size 0.58 mi Distance
8 Anita Dr Sayville, NY 11782SF	$1,250,000 09/23/2024	1983	3	5	2,625 +125	14,810	0.12 mi
8 Anita DrSF Sayville, NY 11782 1983 Built 2,625 +125 Sqft 14,810 Lot Size 0.12 mi Distance
17 Sunset Dr Sayville, NY 11782SF	$860,000 02/25/2025	1938	3	2	2,021 -479	10,019	0.60 mi
17 Sunset DrSF Sayville, NY 11782 1938 Built 2,021 -479 Sqft 10,019 Lot Size 0.60 mi Distance
117 Handsome Ave Sayville, NY 11782SF	$1,350,000 02/13/2025	1926	4	3	3,600 +1,100	29,185	0.60 mi
117 Handsome AveSF Sayville, NY 11782 1926 Built 3,600 +1,100 Sqft 29,185 Lot Size 0.60 mi Distance

Homes For Sale

near 119 Atlantic Ave

Address	Price	Built	Beds	Baths	Sqft	Lot Size	Distance
86 Foster Ave Sayville, NY 11782MF	$799,990 89 days ago	1900	5	3	2,400 -100difference	12,197	1.10 mi
86 Foster AveMF Sayville, NY 11782 1900 Built 2,400 -100 Sqft 12,197 Lot Size 1.10 mi Distance
112 Dale Dr Oakdale, NY 11769SF	$699,000 81 days ago	1956	4	3	2,667 +167	—	1.30 mi
112 Dale DrSF Oakdale, NY 11769 1956 Built 2,667 +167 Sqft — Lot Size 1.30 mi Distance
60 Lincoln Ave Sayville, NY 11782MF	$799,000 36 days ago	1877	4	2	2,694 +194	11,761	1.26 mi
60 Lincoln AveMF Sayville, NY 11782 1877 Built 2,694 +194 Sqft 11,761 Lot Size 1.26 mi Distance
278 Suydam Ln Bayport, NY 11705SF	$1,095,000 73 days ago	1920	3	2	2,700 +200	56,628	1.55 mi
278 Suydam LnSF Bayport, NY 11705 1920 Built 2,700 +200 Sqft 56,628 Lot Size 1.55 mi Distance
2 Westgate Dr Sayville, NY 11782SF	$2,299,000 3 days ago	1955	4	4	2,750 +250	15,246	0.55 mi
2 Westgate DrSF Sayville, NY 11782 1955 Built 2,750 +250 Sqft 15,246 Lot Size 0.55 mi Distance

Schools

serving 119 Atlantic Ave

School Name	Rating	Grades	Parent Rating	Distance
Sayville High School 20 Brook Street, West Sayville, NY 11796	8 / 10	9−12		0.88 mi
9−12 Grades Parent Rating 0.88 mi Distance
Prince Of Peace Regional School 200 West Main Street, Sayville, NY 11782	—	K−8		0.80 mi
K−8 Grades Parent Rating 0.80 mi Distance
Cherry Avenue Elementary School 155 Cherry Avenue, West Sayville, NY 11796	7 / 10	K−5	—	1.15 mi
K−5 Grades — Parent Rating 1.15 mi Distance
West Sayville Christian School 37 Rollstone Avenue, West Sayville, NY 11796	—	K−9		0.59 mi
K−9 Grades Parent Rating 0.59 mi Distance

Show more Hide

School service boundaries are intended to be used as reference only. To verify enrollment eligibility for a property, contact the school directly.

Flood Factor

for 119 Atlantic Ave

8 ^|10

Severe

FEMA Zone (Est.)

X (unshaded)

Flood insurance:

Recommended

Flood risks are increasing as sea levels rise and weather patterns change.

This property has a Severe Flood Factor .

Flood Factor data provided by FloodFactor.